Ideas · · 5 min read
What secular Buddhism means
A this-life reading of the early Buddhist teachings: where the word secular comes from, what this approach keeps, what it sets aside, and what it is not.
People meet the phrase secular Buddhism in different ways. Some come to it after a mindfulness course and want to know what sits behind the techniques. Some grew up in a Buddhist family and drifted away from the temple but not from the ideas. Others read a book, liked the ethics and the attention to experience, and could not get past rebirth or a cosmic law of karma. This note sets out, as plainly as we can, what the phrase usually means and what it does not.
The word "secular" is older than the argument
Secular comes from the Latin saeculum, which meant an age or a generation: roughly the span of a human lifetime. Long before it meant "not religious", it meant "of this age", "of this world", as opposed to the eternal.
That older sense is the useful one here. A secular reading of Buddhism is not mainly an argument against religion. It is an attempt to read the teachings from inside a single human lifetime, in the world as we find it, without first having to accept claims about other lives or other worlds. It asks what the teachings say about how to live here, among the people and problems in front of us.
What the approach keeps
Most people who describe their practice as secular keep a recognisable core of the early teachings:
- Attention to experience. The early discourses spend a great deal of time on noticing what is actually happening in the body, in feelings and in the mind, rather than on doctrine. That emphasis carries over almost untouched.
- The four truths read as tasks. Instead of four propositions to believe, the four noble truths are often read as four things to do: understand suffering, let go of the craving that feeds it, notice when it stops, and cultivate a way of life that makes that stopping more likely. There is a separate note on the four tasks.
- Ethics as practice. Restraint in speech and action, honest work, and care for others are not treated as rules handed down, but as the ground on which any steadier life is built.
- Meditation as training, not escape. Sitting practice is seen as a way of becoming familiar with one's own habits, not a way of leaving the world. See Why people meditate in ordinary life.
What it sets aside, or holds lightly
The early texts were composed in a world that took rebirth, many realms of existence and the moral working of karma across lifetimes for granted. A secular reading generally does one of two things with those ideas:
- Brackets them. It treats them as questions it cannot settle and does not need to settle in order to practise. This is sometimes called an agnostic position.
- Reads them as the background assumptions of the time. On this view, the Buddha spoke in the vocabulary of his culture, and the more distinctive part of his teaching lies elsewhere: in what he said about attention, craving, and the conditions under which suffering arises and fades.
There is some support for holding hard metaphysical questions at arm's length in the texts themselves. In a well-known discourse, the Buddha declines to answer a set of questions about whether the world is eternal or whether a realised person exists after death, and compares someone who insists on answers before practising to a man shot with a poisoned arrow who refuses treatment until he knows who fired it (MN 63 on SuttaCentral). That passage does not prove a secular reading is right, and traditional teachers read it differently. But it shows that "set the unanswerable aside and deal with the arrow" is not a modern invention.
Where the term comes from
The phrase became common in English-language discussion in the early twenty-first century, although the ideas behind it are older. The British writer Stephen Batchelor is the name most often connected with it: his books Buddhism Without Beliefs (1997), Confession of a Buddhist Atheist (2010) and After Buddhism (2015) argue for reading the Buddha as a historical person teaching a practical way of life, and for treating the four truths as tasks. Many people who call themselves secular Buddhists have never read those books, and many who have read them disagree with parts of them. It is a loose movement of readers and practitioners, not a school with a founder or a creed.
What secular Buddhism is not
A few misunderstandings are worth clearing up.
- It is not "Buddhism minus the hard parts". Taking suffering, craving and ethics seriously without the support of a traditional framework is, if anything, more demanding. There is no ritual or lineage to lean on.
- It is not the same as mindfulness courses. Many workplace or clinical mindfulness programmes teach attention techniques with no ethical or philosophical frame at all. A secular Buddhist approach keeps the frame: the techniques serve a way of living, not the other way round.
- It is not a verdict on traditional Buddhists. Millions of people practise within Theravada, Mahayana and Vajrayana traditions, and find in rebirth and ritual something meaningful and true. A secular reading is one way among several of relating to an old and varied body of teaching. There is more on this in Facing tradition and a secular approach.
- It is not anti-religious by definition. Some secular practitioners are atheists, some are agnostic, some belong to other faiths. What they share is a decision to start from this life.
A test you can apply yourself
One of the most quoted passages in this area is the advice given to the Kālāmas, a community confused by competing teachers. The Buddha tells them not to accept something simply because of oral tradition, lineage, scripture, logic alone or the reputation of the speaker, but to judge by what, when taken up and practised, actually leads to harm or to welfare (AN 3.65 on SuttaCentral).
The passage is sometimes stretched to mean "believe whatever you like", which it does not say: the same discourse goes on to say plainly what the Buddha thinks those results will be. But its central move, test teachings against their effects in a life, is close to the heart of the secular approach.
Starting from here
If you want to explore this way of reading the teachings, there is no membership to take out and nothing to sign. A few practical places to start:
- Read a handful of early discourses in a reliable translation, slowly, and notice what strikes you. Reading early Buddhist texts without dogma has suggestions.
- Try a short, regular sitting practice at home. Establishing a home practice covers the basics.
- Keep the questions you cannot answer as questions. A secular reading is comfortable with "I don't know".
For a careful scholarly overview of what is known about the historical Buddha and the early teachings, the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on the Buddha is a sound, readable place to begin.